The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About20100706 - VIII-B-5Memo To: Mayor Hicks and City Council Members From: Kari Barker, Associate Planner, AICP Date: July 6, 2010 Subject: Carl Fultz — Original Hastings Design Standards Review #2010 -33 — Garage — 526 7 St. West REQUEST Carl Fultz is proposing to build a 288 square foot garage at 526 7 St. West. The property is subject to Original Hastings Design Standard (OHDS) requirements because the proposed improvements exceed 5% of the home's current building market value. Therefore, the proposal is subject to Planning Commission review and City Council approval. PLANNING COMMISSION At its June 28, 2010, meeting, the Planning Commission voted 6 -0 to recommend approval of the OHDS review for the garage. ATTACHMENTS • Resolution • Application • Garage plans • Site location map • Garage location map BACKGROUND INFORMATION Comprehensive Plan Classification The property conforms to the Comprehensive Plan. The Plan designates the property as U -1 — Urban Residential (1 -3 units per acre). Zoning Classification The subject property is zoned R- 2 \OHDS — Residential Medium Density \Original Hastings Design Standards. Homes in the R -2 district without a garage are allowed up to two accessory structures with a combined total of 1,000 square feet. Adjacent Zoning and Land Use The following land uses abut the property: Direction Existing Use Zoning Comp Plan North Single Family Home R- 2 \OHDS U -1 — Res. East Single Family Home R- 2 \OHDS U -1 — Res. South Single Family Home R- 2 \OHDS U -1 — Res. West Single Family Home R- 2 \OHDS U -1 — Res Existing Condition The home was constructed in 1900. Proposed Condition There currently is not a garage on the property, though there is a small storage shed. There is an existing curb cut for the driveway. The OHDS state that new garages directly accessing a public street shall be prohibited if an improved alley way abuts the property. As there is not an alley abutting the property, a driveway accessing a public street is allowed. OHDS REVIEW OHDS Intent Original Hastings Design Standards (OHDS) preserve and enhance traditional neighborhood design by reflecting the general characteristics of buildings dating from 1845 to 1940, which is the predominate era for building construction within the OHDS District. OHDS regulations ensure traditional neighborhood design by incorporating design features such as alleys, carriage houses, front porches, period sensitive housing design, sidewalks, and traditional street lighting. Design standards create and enhance the character of older neighborhoods by establishing regulation to guide property development and rehabilitation consistent with the unique historic character of the neighborhood. The OHDS are derived from the Design Guidelines for Original Hastings, adopted in 2003 by the City Council as part of the Heart of Hastings Master Plan. OHDS regulations are located found in Chapter 155.23, Subd. D of the Hastings City Code. Materials The applicant is proposing to use vinyl siding in a staggered cedar pattern on the garage to match the materials on the front porch area of the home. Per the OHDS guidelines, this type of siding is acceptable provided there is a maximum of 5 inches exposed. In addition, the applicant proposes to use asphalt shingles on the roof of the garage, which will have an 8:12 pitch. The bottom portion of the garage will be rock face concrete, similar to retaining wall blocks. The garage doors will be carriage style. HASTINGS CITY COUNCIL RESOLUTION NO. A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HASTINGS GRANTING ORIGINAL HASTINGS DESIGN STANDARDS REVIEW APPROVAL FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF A NEW GARAGE AT 526 7TH STREET WEST - CARL FULTZ Council member and moved its adoption: introduced the following Resolution WHEREAS, Carl Fultz has petitioned for an application to construct a new garage at 526 7 Street West legally described as follows: Lot 12, Block 42, Addition No 13, Dakota County, Minnesota; and WHEREAS, property improvements are subject to City Code Chapter 155.07, Subd. (D)- Original Hastings Design Standards; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission of the City of Hastings recommended approval of the request. NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HASTINGS AS FOLLOWS: That the City Council concurs with the recommendation of the Planning Commission and hereby approves the Original Hastings Design Standards Review as presented to the City Council subject to the following conditions: 1) Proposed plans must be completed consistent with the plans presented to the Planning Commission. 2) Approval of a building permit. 3) Approval is subject to a one year Sunset Clause; if significant progress is not made towards construction of the proposal within one year of City Council approval, the approval is null and void. 4) The siding must not exceed a maximum of 5 inches exposed. 5) Garage must be 5 feet from the side property line. Council member moved a second to this resolution, and upon being put to a vote it was unanimously adopted by all Council members present. Adopted by the Hastings City Council on July 6, 2010, by the following vote: Ayes: Nays: Absent: ATTEST: Paul J. Hicks, Mayor Melanie Mesko Lee, City Clerk (City Seal) I HEREBY CERTIFY that the above is a true and correct copy of resolution presented to and adopted by the City of Hastings, County of Dakota, Minnesota, on the 6 th day of July, 2010, as disclosed by the records of the City of Hastings on file and of record in the office. Melanie Mesko Lee, City Clerk (SEAL) This instrument drafted by: City of Hastings (KSB) 101 4th St. East Hastings, MN 55033 Land Use Application Address or PID of Property: ra Za .5 Z of _ Applicant Name: r �� Z._._ Property Owner: Address: Address: Phone: z� Fax: Email: -r1 Phone: Fax: _ Email: Description of Request: 1-2 'r If requesting site plan review of multi- family units (three or more attached), are the units intended to be for sale or rental units? Check Applicable Line(s) Please Note; All Fees and Escrows are due at time of application. Site Plan $500 + escrow Total Amount Due: $ Make checks payable to City of Hastings. Credit cards also accepted. Please ensure that all copies of required documents are attached. Rezone $500 Minor Subdivision $500 Final Plat $600 Special Use Permit $500 Variance $250 _ Comp Plan Amend, $500 Vacation $400 Lot Split/ Lot Line Adj. $50 House Move $500 Annexation $500 phis legal expenses Prelim Plat $500 + escrow EAW $500 + $1,000 escrow Appli iature Date Applicant Name and Title - Please Print C OwneileiCnAtfrre Date Owner Name - Please Print OFFICIAL USE ONLY He # Fee Paid: Rec'd By: Receipt # Date Rec'd: App. Complete E.W. Concrete and Masonry LLC. Hastings (651) 437 -2642 Cell (657) 226 -3464 P.O. Box 672 Hastings,Md.55033 Date: 6/112010 Invoice 3241 Job: New Foundation and floor for new garage. Name: Carl Fultz Location: 526 W 7th st. Hastings, MN.55033 Phone: 651 - 675 -8590 Item Price: 1 Escavating for new foundation would include di ,backfll and g rading up to slab. All soil to be compacted. $1,200.00 2 Pour new 8" by 16" concrete footings for new frost footings and rockfaced block above grade. Pour 4" reinforced concrete floor. Place cuts and sealers. A concrete corefill will be placed eve 4' for additional reinforcement with a #4 rebar virticall . Thank You. Escavating is Itemized. Total $5,340.00 COMMENTS: Please call me if you have any questions. 9000 E. POINT DOUGLAS RD. IDEAL Door Estimate 06/13/2010 COTTAGE GROVE, MN 55016 Phone: (651) 459-8002 Fax: (651) 459 -7732 Store # 3114 Store ID: COTT MENA D-s Total Sale = $684.68 * SALE PRICES VALID THROUGH SUNDAY, JUNE 13, 2010 * ** If purchased today, you save $73.58 * ** This is an estimate. It is given only for general price information. This is not an offer and there can be no legally binding contract between the parties rased upon this estimate. The prices stated herein are subject to change depending upon the market conditions. The prices stated on this estimate are not firm for an lime period unless specifically written otherwise on'this form. The avaltabflit of materials Is subject to inventory conditions. M NARDS IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY LOSS INCURRED BY THE CUSTOM R WHO RELIES ON PRICES SET FORTH HEREIN OR ON THE AVAILABILITY OFANY OFTHE MATERIALS STATED HEREIN. All Information on this .form, other than price has been provided by customer and Menards Is not responsible for any errors in the information on this estimate, including but not limited to quantity, dimension and quality. please examine this estimate carefully. MENARDS MAKES NO REPRESENTATIONS, ORAL WRITTEN OR OTHERWISE THAT THE MATERIALS LISTED ARE SUITABLE FOR ANY PURPOSE BEING CONSIDERRD BY THE CUSTOMER, BECAUSE, OF WIDE VARIATIONS IN CODES, THERE ARE NO REPRESENTATIONS THAT THE MATERIALS LISTED HEREIN MEET YOUR CODE REQUIREMENTS. PRICE EXTENDED QTY DESCRIPTION SKU EACH PRICE 1 MODEL = MR1LP -ARCH1 INSERT Long Panel Carriage House Emboss R -Value 6.3 1 3/8" Three Layer Insulated Premium Stamped Steel Door Width = 9' Door Height = 7' Finish = Dark Oak Steel SECTIONS: 4 PANELS: 2 STRUTS: 0 TRACK SIZE: 2" MOUNT: Bracket HANDLE: Dectorative Spade Lift Handles 400 -0308 *$550.37 *$550.37 1 LIFT: 12" Radius Standard Torsion Spring Requires 1'2" Of Headroom 425 -8418 *$21.60 *$21.60 1 LOCK: Not Included For A MR1LP- -ARCH1 INSERT Door 400 -0307 $0.00 $0.00 1 CENTER STILE: Not Included For A MR1LP -ARCH1 INSERT Door 400 -0307 $0.00 $0.00 4 Spade ,Strap Hinge (0123190) For A MR1LP -ARCH1 INSERT Door 400--0308 $5.61 $22.44 1 Dark Oak Color Option For Model MR1LP -ARCH1 INSERT Door 425 -7785 *$90.27 *$90.27 Total Sale = $684.68 * SALE PRICES VALID THROUGH SUNDAY, JUNE 13, 2010 * ** If purchased today, you save $73.58 * ** This is an estimate. It is given only for general price information. This is not an offer and there can be no legally binding contract between the parties rased upon this estimate. The prices stated herein are subject to change depending upon the market conditions. The prices stated on this estimate are not firm for an lime period unless specifically written otherwise on'this form. The avaltabflit of materials Is subject to inventory conditions. M NARDS IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY LOSS INCURRED BY THE CUSTOM R WHO RELIES ON PRICES SET FORTH HEREIN OR ON THE AVAILABILITY OFANY OFTHE MATERIALS STATED HEREIN. All Information on this .form, other than price has been provided by customer and Menards Is not responsible for any errors in the information on this estimate, including but not limited to quantity, dimension and quality. please examine this estimate carefully. MENARDS MAKES NO REPRESENTATIONS, ORAL WRITTEN OR OTHERWISE THAT THE MATERIALS LISTED ARE SUITABLE FOR ANY PURPOSE BEING CONSIDERRD BY THE CUSTOMER, BECAUSE, OF WIDE VARIATIONS IN CODES, THERE ARE NO REPRESENTATIONS THAT THE MATERIALS LISTED HEREIN MEET YOUR CODE REQUIREMENTS. Design# 386 Pa e 1 o s Selected: Gable roof w18112 pitch, standard Trusses 2' O.C. Truss Design Location Zip Code; 55033 2x4 Wall Framing Material 12' VVide X 24' Deep X 10' High Newtown Vinyl Double 4" Lap Siding - Sterling Gray 7116" OSB Wall Sheathing Gorilla Wrap 12" gablelf ? eave overhangs 7116" OSB Roof Sheathing yr. Casilebrook, Heatherstone Gray Shingles ngoose Ridge Vert dar Soffit & Fascia Galvanized Regular Roof Edge 1- Garage Door Opener Cedar Overhead Door Jamb Options Selected: The options you have selecled are; 15 LB Roof Felt 1- Surface Mount Block(s) Anchor Balls Today's estimated base price; $1,869,99 The base price includes; 0" Eave10" Gable Overhangs, Framing Malerials, 7116 OSB Roof Sheathing, 20 yr. Fiberglass Class -Onyx Black Shingles, Pine Fascia, Galvanized Regular Roof Edge, 8" Textured Vertical Hardboard Siding, No Service Doors, No Overhead Doors, No Windows, or Any Other Optiors. Front Vien Back View Today's estimeated price: $3,594,65 If purchased Way, you save; $101,30 Monthly BIG Card payment: $100,96 ` Take this sheet to the Building Materials counte( to purchase your materials,'** A!l informalion on ibis form. other than price, has been proyded by guest and Msnards is not responsible fcr any eTors in the information on this estimale, induding but not limited to quanay. dimension and qua,iy. Rea.e e�ar7ine t`is eslimafe carefully MENARDS MAKES NO REPRESENTATIONS, ORAL, WRITTEN OR OTHERWISE, TWAT THE MATERIALS LISTEDA,RE SUITABLE FOR ANY PURPOSE BEING CONSIDERED 3Y THE GUEST BECAJSE OF THE AIDE VARIATIONS IN CODES. THERE ARE NO REPRESENTATIONS THAT THE MATERIALS LISTED HEREIN MEET YOUR CODE REQUIREMENTS. Design# 36621 Here are the wall configurations for your design. Illustration May Not Depict All Options Selected 6 F 1 Gable Front View (1) - 9X7 WHITE INSUE RAISEDPNLEZSETTORSN Ml4SV V-10" X 2'-6" Eave Front View � 1 � - 22"X30" WHITE ALUM! SH UTILITY C60 1 - CP1 FLUSH STEEL DOOR PH 32X80 RH SB Building Size: 12 feet wide X 24 feet long X 10 feel high Approximate Peak Heighi:14 feel 6 inches (973 inches) I I 2'-8" X 6' -8" Gable Back View Eave Back Vievr Menards provided material eslimaies are intended as a general construction aid and have been calculated using typical construction methods. Because of the wide variable in codes and site resirclions, all final plans and material lists must be verified with your Iota# zoning office,archilect and/or builder for building design and code compliance. Mlenards is a supplier of construction materials and does not assume liability for design, engineering or the completeness of any material lists provided. Underground electrical, phone and gas ernes should be located and marked before your building plans are finalized. Remember to use safely equipment including dust masks and sight and hearing proleclion during construclion to ensure a positive building experience. f n� - -_ 12 Gable Front View (1) - 9X7 WHITE INSUE RAISEDPNLEZSETTORSN Ml4SV V-10" X 2'-6" Eave Front View � 1 � - 22"X30" WHITE ALUM! SH UTILITY C60 1 - CP1 FLUSH STEEL DOOR PH 32X80 RH SB Building Size: 12 feet wide X 24 feet long X 10 feel high Approximate Peak Heighi:14 feel 6 inches (973 inches) I I 2'-8" X 6' -8" Gable Back View Eave Back Vievr Menards provided material eslimaies are intended as a general construction aid and have been calculated using typical construction methods. Because of the wide variable in codes and site resirclions, all final plans and material lists must be verified with your Iota# zoning office,archilect and/or builder for building design and code compliance. Mlenards is a supplier of construction materials and does not assume liability for design, engineering or the completeness of any material lists provided. Underground electrical, phone and gas ernes should be located and marked before your building plans are finalized. Remember to use safely equipment including dust masks and sight and hearing proleclion during construclion to ensure a positive building experience. Design 38621 Page I of 4 611312010 0 ;,ao''c� w �0, cs ^ x — O n 6 7 7, c N OD n a rt n a T � ( P?; Ll 9 � �ro a zo � °'3 9' � cn h O O n N N N xx sx z x M-,J -. DU N�u� T °° G: N- W T m zz O P � fuN aChNp II it I. M• p- p- �� x x x xxg. 0 C Z �3; G C� N�� NNNIti I€ I� II li I m V G cc p .P A W CG f: Gh N W U1 N I 1 p Q I! 0 � Od��7 ao o .a S; 'qD: ' `W O P[l.+:a i 6 12 t"s �OC7C� non 000 0-0- �p(ra NNO .o-c,rn i a�n wn�tz �n I w z. C7 p I l i Q C �� I P p � I S!i N yi U7 9� 5-0-a r x v II � c� z O LI J i0 i I ' I x W v I I h 'a I v II� .M1 11 J. w � _ r f ! O E f / v a x� y 1 A , 38621 ! � �� Pag . \ f . . \gip A } \ o \ 113/20 [ � n � M / % \ & = a \ \)' =c - =I &_§\ -gx \\ \( $7)} �§ /( \ \] / \/ \ /3 ! {\ � c, > &/ \ )\ S �\ \ : \\ \ g3 5 /{ \ ®ƒ \ /\ 8 �� \ \� \ E / \ \ \ / \ � . \ { @ m \ \ ( } / ) j \ 2 \ } a ? t ; § , Design# 38621 � �� Page 3 of 4 6113!2010 R v v u v i CZU - omaN 4 Wro� a� Do g ro C N R A wW o 7- CL rn m DTI Q C = N m fil A a o 4 ° 67-` v B L cr rp N G ro m �fl[�7G7f�C�} NN FPF � xAm //yy l V! �• WW h onopu a � O C L7C� � �rWiu m N Ut Cn o co a m� A d d 55 ! O m 00 � o o m cscaa� Co co to a o� ro r�u8 o� g lJ A A - O 7 503 N ° Q c a �ti c o N - o --I O o f r w a � - dO !'1 - o -'o c ' o c 4i x' C a. c cm a Is 0 V w o cJ _ N f co J c .T. s= v 5 c n O U 1 �tL Design 38621 Pag e 4 of 4 A'�Mllm'P 6/13/2010 fl � ; S 7, -9 z ' B fl 3 jD a. D- s Z' ' 0 - G G X 5 7 crl 0— 0 — OL fro w Cl W cl w LZ rQ co Cl) ID LOCATION OF GARGAGE